I think it may have been Eric Peterson‘s idea, originally, to compile a list of my favorite records of the last decade. He mentioned it earlier in the year, and I pretty much forgot all about it. Then, when lamenting that I could barely come up with a Top 10 list for 2009 (which was shocking after 2008 proved to be such a good year for my music library), he reminded me. “Top ten of the decade, man.” And why not? What better decade to evaluate than the one in which I came of age musically? I was 15 in 2000, just finding out about Weezer and Jimmy Eat World and The Get Up Kids and Sunny Day Real Estate and the like. I had a long road ahead of me. Ten years later, here I am. So this is it. I painstakingly went through more or less my entire record collection, pulling out my favorites and plugging them into an Excel spreadsheet. Then—and this was the truly painful part—I took to ranking them the best I could.
A few words on the ranking: first of all, it was, of course, a highly subjective process. There’s no way to truly rank 100 albums hierarchically. But what I tried to do was quickly weigh each album against several criteria, and say, “Based on those criteria, do I enjoy this album more or less than the last on the list?” I did that 100 times, and here we are. These are the general criteria I put into effect:
– Determine whether the record stands the test of time. Certain albums I loved in high school and my first year or two in college, for example, aren’t even on my radar anymore, whereas others I could (and in many cases, do) listen to on a daily basis and never tire of them. Some of the records on this list, once considered great, sound a bit dated, and sometimes this interferes with my enjoyment of the album to varying degrees.
– Determine whether the album elicits a visceral, emotional response, and to what degree. Those albums exist which are universally known amongst music critics and music fans to be “great” (the same way there are those universally known to be total shit), but I tried to ignore all outside influence and think about the emotional or instinctual impact each album has or has had on me. It’s impossible, of course, to rule out cases of sentimentality (some of these records are tied to very specific moments in time, events in my life, etc., and maybe I like them a little more than I should, or would otherwise), but I tried to consider what effect the album has on 25-year-old, December-2009-in-Denver-Colorado-Patrick.
Also, I’m sure there are tons of albums I missed, and I completely welcome your comments that go, “What? So-and-so is nowhere to be found? You, sir, are a joke! Consider our friendship expired!” But these are the ones that, forever reason, I connected with, spent time with, the ones that warranted repeat listens, etc. I make no case for this being a definitive or complete list of the music of the twenty-oughts. As my friend Crawford Philleo (of Hot Congress fame and glory) put it in opening his list, “I think it’d be a good thing to come back in five years and have another stab at it… this one’s already fraught with disaster.” It’s unlikely I’ll actually do that, but it’s possible this could all change with age and wisdom. What I’m doing is freezing it all in time right now.
– I allowed duplicates. For example, there are four Walkmen albums on the list, because I just like The Walkmen that much. Also, I tend to dig up a band’s full discography (or at least more than a couple records) if I really like them, and spend some time with each of them. When compiling his list, Crawford didn’t allow duplicates (except in a couple cases), but I thought I’d do this completely up-front. If I like three albums by one band more than I like one album by another band, so be it. That’s the truth, that’s reflected in my listening habits, so it may as well be reflected in my list.
Also, one interesting trend I noticed (hooray for statistics!): the year most represented on my list is 2001, when I was a junior in high school. However, very few records from that early in the decade trickled into my top 10, whereas there are two albums from 2008 in the top 10. I think this says something interesting about the way music ages, my visceral vs. sentimental relationship to certain albums, etc.
Another note: I stole Crawford’s format, except I bolded the name of the album instead of the name of the artist, since the album is what I’m evaluating in each case. Take that, Crawford! Your Technique +1! Also, in case you’re not used to these sorts of things, the name of the album is followed with the release year and the label on which it was released.
Anyway, enough preamble. Pre-ramble. Here’s the list, but upside-down and with its head cut off; I’m going to post numbers 10 through 1 with write-ups justifying the position of each in the next few days, culminating, hopefully (if I can get my shit together) on New Years Eve. Then? Then I can start taking mental notes for my Top Ten Albums 2010-2019 list, which I’ll be compiling when I’m 35. O terrible future!
If you have some kind of sick desire to keep up with my listening habits, I have a fascinating and beautiful last.fm page. Add me! Send me music! Marvel at the several thousand times I’ve listened to The Cocteau Twins!
Anyway: to the list!
100. The Albacore Pageant – The Lung Chinese Grocery Co. (2001, Breakfast Anytime)
99. Poulain – For Passengers EP (2003, Fiddler)
98. The xx – The xx (2009, XL)
97. Chequerboard – Penny Black (2008, RMG Digital)
96. Sunday’s Best – The Californian (2002, Polyvinyl)
95. My Morning Jacket – Z (2005, ATO)
94. The Stratford 4 – Love & Distortion (2003, Jet Set)
93. Burning Airlines – Identikit (2001, DeSoto)
92. I Am Robot and Proud – Grace Days (2003, Catmobile)
91. Passion Pit – Chunk of Change EP (2008, Columbia/Frenchkiss)
90. Unwed Sailor – The Faithful Anchor (2001, Burnt Toast Vinyl)
89. Silversun Pickups – Carnavas (2006, Dangerbird)
88. This Will Destroy You – Young Mountain EP (2006, Magic Bullet)
87. The Dismemberment Plan – Change (2001, DeSoto)
86. Boards of Canada – Geogaddi (2002, Warp)
85. mono – One Step More and You Die (2002, Arena Rock)
84. 光田康典 & Millennial Fair – Creid (2001, JMS)
83. Radiohead – Kid A (2000, Parlophone/Capitol)
82. Tristeza – Dream Signals in Full Circles (2000, Tiger Style)
81. Pinback – Blue Screen Life (2001, Ace Fu)
80. Caspian – The Four Trees (2006, Dopamine)
79. Bright Eyes – Lifted or The Story is in the Soil, Keep Your Ear to the Ground (2002, Saddle Creek)
78. The Sea and Cake – Car Alarm (2008, Thrill Jockey)
77. I Am Robot and Proud – The Electricity in Your House Wants to Sing (2006, Darla)
76. The Appleseed Cast – Two Conversations (2003, Tiger Style)
75. Beach House – Devotion (2008, Carpark)
74. Be Your Own Pet – Be Your Own Pet (2006, XL)
73. Asobi Seksu – Citrus (2006, Friendly Fire)
72. Rilo Kiley – More Adventurous (2004, Brute/Beaute)
71. Tokyo Police Club – Elephant Shell (2008, Saddle Creek)
70. The Radio Dept. – Lesser Matters (2003, Labrador)
69. Ryan Adams – Love is Hell (2004, Lost Highway)
68. Airiel – The Battle of Sealand (2007, Highwheel)
67. The Avalanches – Since I Left You (2000, Modular)
66. Camera Obscura – Let’s Get Out of This Country (2006, Merge)
65. Rilo Kiley – The Execution of All Things (2002, Saddle Creek)
64. Modest Mouse – The Moon & Antarctica (2000, Epic)
63. Feist – Let It Die (2005, Interscope)
62. Marnie Stern – This Is It and I Am It and You Are It and So Is That and He Is It and She Is It and It Is It and That Is That (2008, Kill Rock Stars)
61. Mice Parade – Bem-Vinda Vontade (2005, FatCat)
60. World’s End Girlfriend – Farewell Kingdom (2001, Noble)
59. Stars – Set Yourself on Fire (2005, Arts & Crafts)
58. Gospel Gossip – Dreamland EP (2009, Guilt Ridden Pop)
57. Yann Tiersen – Amelie (soundtrack) (2001, Virgin)
56. The Velvet Teen – Elysium (2004, Slowdance)
55. Jon Brion (et al.) – Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (soundtrack) (2004, Hollywood)
54. Various Artists – Lost in Translation (soundtrack) (2003, Emperor Norton)
53. Joanna Newsom – The Milk-Eyed Mender (2004, Drag City)
52. Godspeed You! Black Emperor – Lift Your Skinny Fists Like Antennas To Heaven (2000, Constellation/Kranky)
51. John Vanderslice – Cellar Door (2004, Barsuk)
50. Neko Case & Her Boyfriends – Furnace Room Lullaby (2000, Mint/Bloodshot)
49. The Strokes – Is This It? (2001, RCA)
48. The Walkmen – “Pussy Cats” Starring The Walkmen (2006, Record Collection)
47. eastern youth – 感受性応答セヨ (2001, Five One Inc.)
46. Candy Claws – In the Dream of the Sea Life (2008, Wave Magic)
45. Panda Bear – Person Pitch (2007, Paw Tracks)
44. Jets to Brazil – Perfecting Loneliness (2002, Jade Tree)
43. John Vanderlice – Pixel Revolt (2005, Barsuk)
42. The Stills – Logic Will Break Your Heart (2003, Vice)
41. The Walkmen – Everyone Who Pretended to Like Me is Gone (2002, Startime)
40. Friends For Heroes – Years in a Costume (2003, Blackhouse)
39. Do Make Say Think – & Yet & Yet (2002, Constellation)
38. The Grace Period – Dynasty (2001, Audio Dregs)
37. Broken Social Scene – Bee Hives (2004, Arts & Crafts)
36. The Album Leaf – Seal Beach EP (2003, Acuarela)
35. Margot & the Nuclear So and So’s – Dust of Retreat (2006, Standard Recording Company)
34. The Walkmen – Bows + Arrows (2004, Record Collection)
33. Bon Iver – For Emma, Forever Ago (2008, Jagjaguwar)
32. The Appleseed Cast – Sagarmatha (2009, The Militia Group)
31. Japancakes – Waking Hours (2004, WARM)
30. Neko Case – Middle Cyclone (2009, ANTI-)
29. Do Make Say Think – Winter Hymn Country Hymn Secret Hymn (2003, Constellation)
28. Candy Claws – Two Airships / Exploder Falls (2008, Pepper Mill)
27. Japancakes – The Sleepy Strange (2001, Kindercore)
26. The Album Leaf – One Day I’ll Be On Time (2001, Tigerstyle)
25. Idlewild – The Remote Part (2002, Parlophone)
24. The Weakerthans – Left and Leaving (2000, G7 Welcoming Committee)
23. TV on the Radio – Dear Science (2008, Interscope)
22. Broken Social Scene – You Forgot It in People (2002, Arts & Crafts)
21. The Thermals – The Body, The Blood, The Machine (2006, Sub Pop)
20. Ides of Space – Sleeping Fractures (2004, Self-Released)
19. eastern youth – 其処カラ何ガ見エルカ (2003, Five One Inc.)
18. Idlewild – 100 Broken Windows (2000, Food)
17. Hey Mercedes – Everynight Fire Works (2001, Vagrant)
16. Broken Social Scene – Broken Social Scene (2005, Arts & Crafts)
15. Animal Collective – Feels (2005, FatCat)
14. Another Blue Door – Haulers (2004, Stinky)
13. WHY? – Alopecia (2008, anticon.)
12. The National – Alligator (2005, Beggars Banquet)
11. The Thermals – More Parts Per Million (2003, Sub Pop)
Numbers 10 through 1 to follow. Thanks for reading my dumb list.